Commentaries

Between Bridges by Gary DeWaal – May 2, 2018 (Actual Delivery; Manipulative Device or Contrivance)

Jump to: Between Bridges    Fraud and Anti-Fraud    My View    Retail Forex and Metals   
Email Print
Published Date: May 02, 2018

California Federal Court Tosses CFTC Enforcement Action Against Precious Metals Dealer, Rejecting Commission View of “Actual Delivery” and “Manipulative or Deceptive Device”

The California federal court judge who, at the end of March, tentatively dismissed the enforcement action by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission against Monex Deposit Company and other defendants for alleged fraud in connection with their financed sale of precious metals to retail persons, issued a final order confirming the dismissal on May 1.

In his ruling, the judge – the Hon. James V. Selna – emphasized the two basic pillars of his tentative order, that: 

  1. actual delivery of precious metals in financed transactions to retail persons falls outside the CFTC’s authority when ownership of real metals is legally transferred to such persons within 28 days even if the seller retains control over the commodities because of the financing beyond 28 days; and 
  2. the CFTC cannot use the prohibition against persons engaging in any manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance in connection with the sale of any commodity in interstate commerce enacted as part of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act to prosecute acts of purported fraud except in instances of fraud‑based market manipulation.

(Click here for background on the CFTC enforcement action and an overview of the tentative order in the article, “California Federal Court Potentially Poised to Limit CFTC’s Dodd-Frank Fraud-Based Anti-Manipulation Authority in Monex Enforcement Action” in the April 22, 2018 edition of Bridging the Week.)

My View: As I indicated in the Legal Weeds section of my earlier article on this enforcement action, this decision has significant implications beyond precious metals. For example, it is very relevant for cryptocurrency exchanges that may desire to provide financing in connection with retail persons’ purchases of virtual currencies and propose to hold such commodities in so-called “multi-sig” wallets they control at least in part. It is also very relevant in considering the application of the CFTC’s Dodd-Frank granted authority to prosecute persons for alleged manipulative or deceptive devices or contrivances in connection with non-market-based fraud.

However, this is just a decision of one federal court in one district of California. It seems likely the CFTC will appeal this decision.

For further information: click here to access a copy of the relevant court’s decision.

The information in this article is for informational purposes only and is derived from sources believed to be reliable as of May 1, 2018. No representation or warranty is made regarding the accuracy of any statement or information in this article. Also, the information in this article is not intended as a substitute for legal counsel, and is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, a lawyer-client relationship. The impact of the law for any particular situation depends on a variety of factors; therefore, readers of this article should not act upon any information in the article without seeking professional legal counsel. Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP may represent one or more entities mentioned in this article. Quotations attributable to speeches are from published remarks and may not reflect statements actually made. Views of the author may not necessarily reflect views of Katten Muchin or any of its partners or other employees.

Recent Commentaries

Categories

Archives



ABOUT GARY DEWAAL

Gary DeWaal

Gary DeWaal is currently Special Counsel with Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP in its New York office focusing on financial services regulatory matters. He provides advisory services and assists with investigations and litigation.


Social Media:

ABOUT KATTEN

Katten is a firm of first choice for clients seeking sophisticated, high-value legal services in the United States and abroad.

Our nationally recognized practices include corporate, financial services, litigation, real estate, environmental, commercial finance, insolvency and restructuring, intellectual property, and trusts and estates.

Our approximately 650 attorneys serve public and private companies, including nearly half of the Fortune 100, as well as a number of government and nonprofit organizations and individuals.

We provide full-service legal advice from locations across the United States and in London and Shanghai.

CONTACT US

Gary DeWaal
Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP
575 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022-2585

+1.212.940.6558




Request Information »

Join Mailing List »